Published August 9, 2006

THEATER REVIEW

Teens rock in 'Surf City, U.S.A.!' premiere

The cast of 'Surf City,USA' rehearse the opening act of the musical during Tuesday night's dress rehearsal at the Huntington Beach Playhouse.

Despite conflicting claims from a certain city to the north, Huntington Beach is, has been and more than likely always will be "Surf City USA." Now there's a new stage musical that verifies this declaration.

Longtime Huntington Beach resident Shirley Westlie Orlando has had her dream realized with the world premiere of her show, "Surf City, U.S.A.!," currently on stage at the Huntington Beach Playhouse. It's a nostalgic tribute to the local surfing culture of 1963, when Dick Dale and the Beach Boys were altering the tone of American music.

For a considerable time, however, "Surf City" is more about teenagers' coming of age than the art of hanging 10. Then, in the show's final scene, we get a surfing championship segment described in language only Gidget and Moondoggie would fully comprehend.

There are 21 performers in "Surf City, U.S.A.!," only three of whom appear old enough to vote. Thus, the tenor is definitely slanted toward the younger generation — and the crises geared accordingly, from unrequited crushes to zits. There's even a bit right out of "Star Wars" in which a young man discovers his true father — and reacts in much the same way as Luke Skywalker did when he learned his daddy was Darth Vader.

Director Roberta Kay, who has a long and impressive pedigree in musical theater, has done her utmost to bring this formulaic new musical to life, and for the most part succeeds. Where the show needs attention desperately is in the area of its recorded music, which often drowns out the young voices attempting to project it, and, to a lesser degree, the tendency of some of the teen actors to rush their dialogue.

The show is brimming with youthful energy, which tends to compensate for its sort of watered-down "Grease"-like plot without that show's infectious pizazz. Teenage angst only can take an audience so far. Orlando, realizing this, has injected some serious side issues, however derivative, into her second act.

The "Surf City" story line centers on a shy guy (Josh Alton) who's crazy about the girl next door (Arroya Karian) but can't advance the relationship beyond friendship. Then the town hunk (Alex Syiek) moves in, with ulterior motives, while his doused flame (Kim Bower) plots revenge.

Alton turns in a fine, layered performance while Karian, though more single-dimensional, shines in her vocal segments. Syiek is a most believable baddie, as is his lieutenant (muscular Shane Cervantes), but their uber-geek follower (Thomas Mastroianni) is strictly an artificial plot device, more silly than funny.

Bower's sultry moves are eye-catching, but the more appealing performances come from the supporting ranks — Kelsey Richardson, Samantha Burbidge and Samantha Bullat (the latter laid low by facial blemishes on the night of the big dance).

The more seasoned players — Mike Bower as a tipsy beach bum/musician and Cory Watkins as Karian's mother and a Huntington High teacher — turn in some of the finest portrayals of the evening. Dan Gonzalez, also in the "mature" category, is charged with delivering all the far-out terms only surfers comprehend in announcing the big event.

Erik Przytulski's musical direction and director Kay's choreography are fine, although the volume level should be lowered for maximum comprehension. This holds especially true for new musicals in which the audience isn't intimately familiar with the lyrics.

Whatever faults "Surf City, U.S.A.!" might possess, however, are overshadowed by the fact that this is a home-grown musical which, if only for that reason, deserves attention. There is an abundance of talent and energy at work here, often offering some pleasant surprises.
 
WHAT: "Surf City, U.S.A.!," the musical

WHERE: The Huntington Beach Central Library Playhouse, 7111 Talbert Ave.

WHEN: 8 p.m. Thu-Sat 3 p.m. matinee on Sat; Sundays at 2 p.m. and 7 p.m. through Aug. 20

COST: $18 to $21
Copyright 2006 Huntington Beach Independent